Our most popular pie! Typically is topped with Oreos and fudge
Choose any two ice cream flavors and toppings. Some popular combinations include: Bittersweet Nugget with Chocolate Chip, Choc. Lover's Choc. with Coconut, Cookie Dough with Chocolate Oreo, Caramel Swirl with Muddy River, and Koffee Chip with Bittersweet Nugget
From a reviewer’s perspective, the menu at Prince Puckler's Ice Cream may be concise, but it highlights a few indulgent frozen treats that are sure to satisfy dessert lovers. The Ice Cream Pies section features options like the Mint Oreo and Oreo pie and a Customize option, allowing guests to tailor a frozen dessert to their own preferences. For those looking for a refreshing handheld treat, the Chocolate Dipped Frozen Bananas stand out as a classic favorite. While prices are not listed, the menu focuses on simple yet appealing frozen specialties that complement the shop’s reputation for sweet, satisfying desserts.